New to Whatnot? Join through my link and get £25 credit! Claim your credit New buyers only. Offer shown at sign-up.

Mystery Scoop Boxes: 100 Orders and a Little More Choice

By Ally • • Approximately 5 min read
Mystery scoop gift box from Ally’s Personal Touch

When I launched my mystery scoop boxes at the end of August, I wasn’t quite sure what to expect. Since then, I’ve sold over 100 boxes, which still feels a bit mad!

I’ve packed boxes for birthdays, Christmas presents, care packages and plenty of “just because” treats. I’ve had requests for everything from pastel stationery and cute animals to dark bookish humour and Highland cows. Some of you know exactly what you like, while others give me a couple of clues and let me get creative.

I’ve really enjoyed putting them together, and I’ve learned a lot along the way. One thing that keeps coming back to me is how important it is to know what you’re buying, even when it’s meant to be a surprise.

If you’re new to my mystery scoops, you can read more about how they work in my first post, Mystery Scoop Boxes UK: Little Surprises with a Personal Touch.

The fun of a surprise, with a little reassurance

I love watching surprise unboxings, but I also know it can be hard to buy something when you don’t really know what’s going to turn up. Everyone has different tastes, and what feels like a great box to one person might not be quite right for someone else.

That’s why I want you to have a say in yours.

You can choose bookish, stationery or self-care, or mix and match the themes. You can also tell me about your favourite colours, hobbies, sense of humour and anything you don’t want included.

Maybe you love pink and anything cow themed. Perhaps you’re after a moody romantasy box, or you’re buying for a teenager and want to keep everything age-appropriate. All those little details help me choose items that fit.

I can’t guarantee a particular colour, design or product will always be available, but I do read your notes and use them when putting your box together. Hopefully, you’ll end up with things you were hoping for, along with a few quirky extras you might not have picked for yourself.

So what are you actually getting?

I’ve recently updated my Etsy listing to make this as clear as possible.

Each scoop contains a minimum of six beads, and each bead represents an item. There are often more than six, but that’s the minimum I guarantee.

You can choose from five boxes:

  • Joy Box: 1 scoop
  • Treat Box: 2 scoops
  • Surprise Box: 3 scoops
  • Deluxe Box: 4 scoops
  • Ultimate Box: 5 scoops

Every box also includes two little extras of your choice. So, including those extras, the Joy Box contains at least eight items and the Ultimate Box contains at least 32.

You can now choose your two little extras

This is the newest change, and I think it makes ordering even better!

Every box has always included extras, but you can now choose the two you’d most like to receive. There’s a selection including pens, pencils, mini notebooks, scrunchies, stickers and bookmarks.

If you know you’ll definitely use a pen and a scrunchie, choose those. If a notebook and bookmark are more your thing, you can pick those instead.

And if you’re happy for me to decide, there’s always Ally’s Choice. 😊

How I put your box together

The beads decide which types of goodies are included, then I use your preferences to bring everything together.

Let’s say you’ve asked for a bookish box with green and neutral colours. I’ll look at the items selected and choose from the designs and colours I have available. I also check the selection as a whole, avoid unnecessary duplicates and make small swaps where needed.

Not every item will always match perfectly, and stock changes all the time, but your notes help me make each box feel more like yours.

Supporting other small businesses

I’ve spent quite a bit of time looking at other mystery scoop sellers, including researching prices. I think it’s important to understand the market and avoid undercutting fellow small businesses.

There’s room for everyone. We all have different products, ideas and ways of putting our boxes together, and I’d much rather see small businesses support each other.

One thing I did notice while looking around is that listings can be quite different in the information they give. Some tell you the value of the box, while others show photos of previous orders. Those photos can be helpful, but sometimes it’s hard to know what size box you’re looking at or what the customer asked for.

There’s nothing wrong with doing things differently, but I know that as a customer, I like having a clear idea of what I’m paying for. That’s why I’ve included the scoop sizes, minimum bead counts and choice of extras in my listing.

Thank you for being here

To everyone who has ordered a box so far, thank you. Whether you’ve treated yourself, sent one as a gift or come back for another, your support means so much to my little business.

Packing more than 100 mystery boxes since the end of August is something I’m really proud of. I’m excited to keep making them, reading your wonderfully varied requests and finding new treats to include.

If you’d like to have a look, you can find the boxes in my Etsy shop.

Ally x


Follow along on Instagram for scoop videos and packing inspiration, or subscribe to the newsletter for more from Ally’s Personal Touch.